I want to know how they are going to save harry, ron, hermione, luna, etc.... from the malfoy manner because they have left dobby out of all the movies except the second. It wouldn't make sense for the people who haven't read the books if an elf saved Harry after not seeing him for 5 years.
that's what i thought but then how would they explain Olivander and Griphook?
I was they would have waited until all of the Harry Potter books had been written so they could of took this kind of stuff into consideration like leaving Dobby in.
I guess there is a lot thats important in that scene. so it will probably stay. heh they'll probably have Neville apparate in and save them all...I don't think he'll die at the end of it though because he still has to kill Nagini. _________________
His death, itself, is just too violent. He's killed by a knife, not a wand; a frigging KNIFE and BLOOD and etc. The producers wouldn't want to live and see a 7-year old walk in then walk out with a permanent scar on his life.
a giant snake was killed when a sword was run through its head. I don't think they're going to balk at killing dobby with a knife stuck in him. _________________
if they do put dobby in the seventh and he dies they better show the burial sceen. that was really sad
It wouldn't have as much effect though, seeing as he wasn't shown in the other movies except one of them. (at least for a person who hasn't read the book) _________________
I guess they could make it kreacher...or they just cut out Malfoy Manor altogether.
oh i can totally see them making it kreacher instead of dobbly, just to show that kreacher was nice and changed and whatnot. but i REALLY hope they use dobby _________________ Bloody Hell!!
i know! i hate how ugly they made him (not like i expected him to be extremely cute or anything). its soo not what i pictured him to look like.
i think at the beginning of one of the chapters of the american versions of hp, although its either in the 5th or 6th book, or may even be in the 7th but i dont think so, there is a picture of kreacher with hair coming out of his ears and everything. but from that picture i had an image in my head of him looking like that
does anyone else kno the picture im talking about? _________________ Bloody Hell!!
i pictured him like older and sort of mean but not like that at all
yes that ones it. and thats more of how i pictured him. the nose and ears in the movie were just way too long. but i actually pictured him more as a kind of meaner variation of dobby. _________________ Bloody Hell!!
It'll just be confusing for people that haven't read the books, to have this character all of a sudden come back and lose his life.
I think as long as they put him in the HBP film it will make it somewhat clearer.
They did a lot of stupid things.. like who will know that Percy is disconnected from his family if they haven't read OotP? _________________
^That's a good point about Percy, I'm preety sure they totally left it out, but I think they'll put Dobby in there anyways. Maybe they'll put him in the 6th, I don't really know, but I think he kind of has to be in the 7th or a lot of important parts would be cut. _________________
Wand:8" Cedar with Unicorn Hair
Animagi:Squirrel
A lot of important parts will be cut anyways.
In the last two books everything is relevant in some way, it's how we understand the plot or the characters actions and choices. _________________
They did a lot of stupid things.. like who will know that Percy is disconnected from his family if they haven't read OotP?
Someone on the board actually asked that recently. They hadn't read the books and asked why Ron's brother was just sort of standing there manhandling Harry and Cho without saying anything to them. _________________ Breathing is optional. Look, Bella, look.
Rules
FAQ
Search
Memberlist
Usergroups
Register
Profile
Log in
Karl Stevanovic is a robot!
