would you keeping reading the harry potter books if JK rowling wrote the same books except from different but important views of other characters. like from dumbdore's POV, or Snape's POV, Ron's, Hermoine's, or maybe even Voldemort's
exp: what was dumbdore really thinking when he was about to die....what was hermoines thinking when she saw ron and lavender kissing (6th book)....and ect.
wouldn't that be interesting to know what the other characters were thinking during The Battle of Hogwarts?? when they knew dumbdore was dead?? what they though after they knew the truth about Snape. What they though of each other when they just met?? How Ron's and Hermoine's relationship started?? and ect...
wouldn't that be great!!! maybe we can convince JK rowling to do that too!!! (it's a long shot but hey!!) I'm trying to get this idea out so HELP ME PLEASE!!! MAYBE IF ENOUGH PEOPLE KNOW AND IF JK ROWLING KNOWS MAYBE SHE CAN CONSIDER IT!!! SO HELP GET THE IDEA OUT!!! THANX!!
yeah, that'd be cool.
however, i do believe that it might ruin the story in a way..
i mean, we've got to ask ourselves questions, one of them being "hmm.. what was he/she thinking at that point?"
i like the mystery of things and using my imagination.
i think that harry's point of view would be the best eitherway. _________________ www.theboywholivedd.piczo.com
name: mona
house: gryffindor
wand: 11" cedar, phoenix feather
Last edited by ilovedan38 on September 14, 2007 2:54 pm; edited 1 time in total
I hate first person books. Most of them r so.....un-professional. I mean some of the Goosebumps books PROVE that lol. _________________ "My Logic is Never without Reason..."
I love the way the books are written, I think it's perfect. We do kind of still know what the other characters were thinking, based on Harry's observations. I don't think the other versions would be necassary. _________________ Blame it on a simple twist of fate. ~ Bob Dylan
I would have liked it if she done it in different peoples point of views at different times. Like who was doing the most important thing at the time. Only one book I have read does that. _________________
I would most definately read them if they came out, but I don't think JKR would get a good response to that. A lot of people would probably just think it was a stupid way to make Harry Potter more popular, to keep it running, and to get more money. I could live without it, but it would be great. _________________ Draco Malfoy and *sniff...sob* Fred Weasly ♥
banner made by Kino
I love the way the books are written, I think it's perfect. We do kind of still know what the other characters were thinking, based on Harry's observations. I don't think the other versions would be necassary.
Agreed, I think it would ruin the effect of the stories _________________
I liked the way the series is written,
in Harry's point of view. Seeing as the series
does revolve around him.
Icefire wrote:
I would most definately read them if they came out, but I don't think JKR would get a good response to that. A lot of people would probably just think it was a stupid way to make Harry Potter more popular, to keep it running, and to get more money. I could live without it, but it would be great.
maybe it would be interesting to know what he thinks and how he has come to think that way... i like that we caught a glimpse of the stuff that goes on in his mind in the bathilda's secret part.... the night when he killed the potters. i thinks its the very first time we really entered into his mind and not just saw what he was up to. _________________
Rules
FAQ
Search
Memberlist
Usergroups
Register
Profile
Log in
