^ jo expressed very well that snape detested harry, didnt give a damn about him and was only protecting him for lily's sake, so i doubt very much any of those attitudes were faked
and it wouldnt explain why he still was aweful in detentions and occlumency lessons
as jo said, he is a really flawed, bitter man, so yeah maybe a bit was for show but i think mostly it was because he meant it
lilyevans wrote:
Yes maybe youre right, it WAS childish and selfish to act like he did, but you have to admit that he hadn't had a really nice time in his life.
So how would you have acted?
not that bad, thats for sure, and i cant really say, im just 19, i havent grown up that much have i? _________________
You are up there!
well thats exaclty my point, if snape was 19 i guess it would be stupid but a bit more logical than if he is 30 something, he is suppossed to know better
i dont know what is to be 30 something, to have such a maturity, but even with this age i can assure you i wouldnt have been as bad as snape, i just dont have it in me to be that mean to an 11 year old _________________
You are up there!
Oh, I would like to see Sev again and to see him speaking with Harry... so sad
mmm...i dont exactly know what you mean by this, because snape pretty much detested harry
Spoiler:
Well, now Harry knows Snape was in love with Lily and he didn't hate him but his father. Whatsoever, I think maybe Snape would have apologized to him or so.
Spoiler:
Why would he hate his father? I get why he wouldnt hate Snape anymore.
_________________ My signature is entirly privet and will not be shown to anyone without permission.
Roses are Red
Violets are blue
I like Harry Potter
How about you?
(because I do not listen rap music )
at the end of the books Harry said that Severus was the bravest man he ever knew
he didnt hate Severus anymore
and they were on about Severus saying Severus hated James not Harry
which he did, Severus hated James and some of it was taken out on Harry
because he was James son
and Harry looked like James
imagine how he felt seeing the face of James everytime he looked at Harry
James was the man who ended up with Lily, the love of Severus's life
Harry did have doubts about his father too, after he saw Severus's memories, but harry realised that James was young then, and teens say and do some stupid things
as proven by Severus calling Lily a mudblood, which i doubt he meant, because he loved her always _________________ SheWho,GinnyX and Ravvy - teh n00bbusters!
busting n00bs whenever they strike!
^thanks Arabella
WWSD?
<3
Well, now Harry knows Snape was in love with Lily and he didn't hate him but his father. Whatsoever, I think maybe Snape would have apologized to him or so.
Spoiler:
Why would he hate his father? I get why he wouldnt hate Snape anymore.
why would he hate james? have u read the books?
and i dont get ur other comment _________________
You are up there!
Well, now Harry knows Snape was in love with Lily and he didn't hate him but his father. Whatsoever, I think maybe Snape would have apologized to him or so.
Spoiler:
Why would he hate his father? I get why he wouldnt hate Snape anymore.
why would he hate james? have u read the books?
and i dont get ur other comment
Ha I think my comment was misunderstood, now you see what I exactly said was; Why would he hate his father? I get why he wouldnt hate Snape anymore. so I DO get why he didnt hate severious Snape anymore.
What I didn't get was; what did James Potter have anything to do with it? Ok, He maybe wasn't so nice to snape. But he had already forgiven him about that in book 5. He understood that his father had changed. So I dont get the reason why Harry Potter would hate James Potter(his father) _________________ My signature is entirly privet and will not be shown to anyone without permission.
Roses are Red
Violets are blue
I like Harry Potter
How about you?
(because I do not listen rap music )
why would harry hate his father right? i agree with you and i think he is always going to like his father better than snape, even if he doesnt hate snape anymore _________________
You are up there!
tonks, mostly for teddy's sake. it sucks for him to grow up without parents, but mostly i think it would be so hard to not have a mother. plus tonks was an awsome character.
but i also miss fred, remus, hedwig and colin creevy.
(if cedric was a choice though i would have chosen him) _________________
DON'T EAT THE DAISIES
tonks, mostly for teddy's sake. it sucks for him to grow up without parents, but mostly i think it would be so hard to not have a mother. plus tonks was an awsome character.
but i also miss fred, remus, hedwig and colin creevy.
(if cedric was a choice though i would have chosen him)
I also choose for the same reason, but Im not sure if I have chosen Tonks or Remus though... _________________ My signature is entirly privet and will not be shown to anyone without permission.
Roses are Red
Violets are blue
I like Harry Potter
How about you?
(because I do not listen rap music )
It was hard to choose between Sirius, Tonks and Lupin for different reasons.
Sirius was really the only person close to family harry had, he was his father's best friend. Harry and he got really close before his death. Lupin or Tonks because Teddy didn't deserve to lose both parents. _________________ I love Wandmaster14 ♥♥♥
Well, now Harry knows Snape was in love with Lily and he didn't hate him but his father. Whatsoever, I think maybe Snape would have apologized to him or so.
Spoiler:
Why would he hate his father? I get why he wouldnt hate Snape anymore.
why would he hate james? have u read the books?
and i dont get ur other comment
Ha I think my comment was misunderstood, now you see what I exactly said was; Why would he hate his father? I get why he wouldnt hate Snape anymore. so I DO get why he didnt hate severious Snape anymore.
What I didn't get was; what did James Potter have anything to do with it? Ok, He maybe wasn't so nice to snape. But he had already forgiven him about that in book 5. He understood that his father had changed. So I dont get the reason why Harry Potter would hate James Potter(his father)
Oh sorry, actually I meant that Snape didn't hate Harry but Harry's father. _________________
'After all this time?' - 'Always'
"...probably the bravest man I ever knew."
I don't think JKR did any justice to her or Lupin's characters in the way they were killed off though... it felt like it was just kind of whimsically thrown in there, you know? _________________
I don't think JKR did any justice to her or Lupin's characters in the way they were killed off though... it felt like it was just kind of whimsically thrown in there, you know?
yeah i know, i wish she would've made a bigger deal out of it _________________
You are up there!
Rules
FAQ
Search
Memberlist
Usergroups
Register
Profile
Log in
