Harry Potter Forums

Posts: 1657 · Joined: Jan 6, 2007 Posts: 1657

Yeah, I re-read through the posts and I found it and even what i stated, was already said. Crying or Very sad

Posts: 15 · Joined: Dec 25, 2006 Location: London Posts: 15

Hermoine is quite like Lily, don't you think?
Maybe this is why he also dislikes her but then again he dislikes everyone. Neutral

Lola.
_________________

Posts: 18 · Joined: Dec 18, 2006 Posts: 18

I agree about the similarity between Hermione and Lily!

Posts: 12 · Joined: Feb 20, 2007 Posts: 12

I think that Snape did have a soft spot for Lily and she knew this and this is why she defended him when James and Sirius picked on him. However, i think Lily did this out of sympathy and never really had any feelings of the romantic kind for Snape. This may be why he reacted the way he did by calling her a Mudblood because Lily had made it clear that she didn't like him that way.

Or it's possible that the notes in the Potions book weren't actually Snapes but Lily's and he was only good at Potions because she helped him.

Posts: 326 · Posted: February 23, 2007 6:38 pm Post subject: how you pictured it.

Since all the speculation is about to come to a close. I decided that it would be nice to Hear people's views on the sequence of events that lead to the whole Harry Potter story. This is my version. I am not saying that it is right.

THEN:

I just thought this up. You know how there's a loop hole on the whole Snape overhearing the prophacy thing. Tralawny knew Snape was listening in. That means she would have been out of her trance. So then wouldn't Snape have heard the whole thing.

So Snape is soooo regretting this whole Death Eater thing. He wants to get out. He tells Voldy only Half of the prophacy. He neglects to mention the : he will have a power the dark lord knows not.

Then Voldy decides he is going to kill the Potters: NO, this is not what severus wanted. Lily was such a wonderful person Bla Bla Bla. he tried to turn Voldy away from the idea that it could be Lily's baby. Now Snape at this point if fairly good at Occlumency. However the power of the thought of Lily dying is too much to keep out of his mind. Voldy sees that he is holding some sort of affection for her.

He deicdes to take pitty ( a rear thing) on Severus because he gave him such good info.

Severus now knows Lily good enough to know that there is no way she's letting Lord Voldypants kill her baby while she quietly watches. He needs to warn her. But no one knows where they are. Ahh Dumbledore must know, he is the leader of the Order

He goes to DD and tells him the story. Dumbledore calls on Lily and James and informs them of the Voldermorts plan. They decide to have a secret keeper. Snape knowing how close James was with Sirius knows it will be Sirius. However he doesnot trust Sirius too much after all his brother is a Death Eater.

Lily is still worried that the plan maynot work. In a private meeting with her old friend Severus she makes him take an unbreakable vow to protect Harry if anything should Happen to her. He reluctantly agrees.

Lily and James go into hiding in Godric's Hollow.

DD is worried about Snape ad the fact that he cannot control his emotions when it comes to Lily. He trains him up a bit so he can spy on Voldy for him. He gives Snape a job as Potions Master to keep him close my. He tells Seveus to convince Voldy that his could work to their advantage.

He sends him back to Voldy.

Voldy who was busy trying to find the Potters fianlly finds them when Wormtail tells him where they are. No one knows about this.

Voldy goes to the Potters and Kills James. He goes to Lily and tells her to step aside, 'Man does Severus owe me'. But she won't move. 'Oh well, might as well kill her anyway'. He kills her. Then Tries to Kill Harry. 'Oh Oh.' he looses his powers.

Now clever little Lilly knew that would happen all along. She knows a fair bit about old Magic. When Severus told her he begged for her life she figured out what she had to do when the need presented itself. She made Snape take the unbreakable vow because she knew Death Eaters would come looking for Harry once Voldy was unable to kill him.

THEN BOOKS ONE THROUGH SIX

Now:

Voldy now trust Snape. 'Wow he actally killed Dumbledore, even I couldn't do it.' The fact that he Killed his precious Lily slips his mind. 'After all he doesn't seem to be all worked up about it when I read his mind'.

Snape hates Voldy: 'That bastard killed the only woman i ever loved. I kill him.' But Snaoe is so good at Occlumency it is now impossible for Voldy to read his mind. He can even implant false memeories.

But the one thing still needs to be taken care off. He still has to keep his Vow to protect Harry. He would have been able to teach him every thing he needed to know had he been given the DADA post but he was never given the opportunity. IF he knew he had swore his life to protect James's child he wouldn't have bothered. Harry was nothing like Lily.

EVENTUALLY

Harry gets trained in all the thigns he needs to know somehow. Severus never reveals he is on the right side to Harry. 'Harry is awful at Occlumency he will get us both killed'.

Harry destroys the Horcrux and When it seems like Voldy is about to kill Harry that when Snape reveals he is Good. He kills Voldy, fulfilling the promise he made to Lily.

And it is done.

What do you think? Write your own Version of the events in the book.
I am not saying that this is right. I'm just saying this is what i pictured Happened.
_________________
Remember, Remember, the 5th of November

Posts: 119 · Joined: Apr 7, 2008 Location: Singapore Posts: 119

Gees, cool theory.
I think Snape had more then just a crush with Lily.
It is the connection that Snape have difficulty putting aside eversince Voldemort Killed her.
_________________

Posts: 17940 · Posted: April 16, 2008 8:33 am Post subject:

Posts: 119 · Joined: Apr 7, 2008 Location: Singapore Posts: 119

Posts: 23236 · Posted: April 19, 2008 7:09 am Post subject:

Posts: 119 · Joined: Apr 7, 2008 Location: Singapore Posts: 119

Posts: 23236 · Posted: April 19, 2008 9:39 am Post subject:

Posts: 17940 · Posted: April 19, 2008 9:57 am Post subject:

Posts: 23236 · Posted: April 19, 2008 10:06 am Post subject:

Posts: 17940 · Posted: April 19, 2008 10:26 am Post subject:

^ exactly, she might have not hated him, but she certainly didnt like him yet
_________________

You are up there!

Posts: 1111 · Posted: April 20, 2008 8:38 am Post subject:

Posts: 41 · Joined: Apr 30, 2008 Location: Wales Posts: 41

Well i think that snape was in love with Lilly.
After reading DH i really couldnt argue with the fact that he was in love with her, when they wer kids you could tell that snape like lilly, and from what i read i thought that they wer rather close throut school, not as close as snaoe wanted to be though, coz he felt that he wasnt suppose to like her as much because she was a muggle born.
This is obvious when he turned around and said "I dont want help from a mudblood" - he was trying to deny the feelings that he had for her, but then he begged her to forgive him and blah blah - which means that he really did regret it, cuz no future death eater is gunna go up 2 a muggleborn and say sorry unless they really have feeling for them.
and also who in their right friggin minds would just waltz up to voldy and ask him not to kill a muggle-born if they dont truly love that person (i bloody wouldnt).
And lastly his potronus turned into a doe, after lilly.

Thats sucked all my brainpower away

Posts: 931 · Joined: Jan 30, 2008 Location: Florida Posts: 931

Sigh.. Severus/Lily is my favorite ship, ever. I only like one other ship.. and that's Tom/Minerva - hey, don't judge!

Anyway.. have you ever figured out why Snape wanted Harry to look into his eyes before he died?

(besides collecting his memories)

Harry had Lily's eyes. Snape wanted it to be the last thing he saw before his death. AWWWW. Sad