Why wouldn't harry grenade the horcruxes in part 7? Could have been effective.
Because in order to destroy a Horcrux you need either fiendfyre or basilisk venom.
or gryffindor's sword
Gryffindor's sword only worked to destroy the Horcruxes because it had basilisk venom embedded in the blade from when Harry stabbed it through the mouth. _________________ ^made by Fiendfyre
would he even know what a gun is though?? since he hates muggles so much he would have nothing to do with their world and might not know what a gun looks like or does...
Remember that he was raised in a Muggle Orphanage. _________________
would he even know what a gun is though?? since he hates muggles so much he would have nothing to do with their world and might not know what a gun looks like or does...
Remember that he was raised in a Muggle Orphanage.
ooh good point! _________________
You are up there!
would he even know what a gun is though?? since he hates muggles so much he would have nothing to do with their world and might not know what a gun looks like or does...
Remember that he was raised in a Muggle Orphanage.
ooh good point!
It was around 1936-37 when Dumbledore came and visited him in the Orphanage when he was 11. So close to WWII, which of course involved guns. _________________
He enjoyed torturing and killing people. Killing people with a gun in an instant couldn't satisfy him.
Everyone said that Harry was the boy who lived. Voldy couldn't touch him. It seemed like Harry had greater magical power than him. He's proud and arrogant. He wanted to show people that he could kill Harry by his own magic, without any help from other people or muggle device.
Voldy with a GUN!? LooooooooooL!
Seriously Voldy liked when his victims were dieing slowly and well with a gun.......hm there is no easier way to die..............just point gun at your head! _________________ You are the weak one!!!You will never know love or friendship and I feel sorry for you!!!
Voldy hated anything to do with muggles, he would never resort to using a muggle weapon. He would view a gun as a poor substitute for magic and way beneath him. _________________ ^made by Fiendfyre
That's correct.I mean Voldy always hated even half-bloods even if he was one of them. _________________ You are the weak one!!!You will never know love or friendship and I feel sorry for you!!!
This conversation is just going in circles now. The points people are making on this page are the same points that were made on the first page. _________________
Please support the Diabetes Walk
Voldy with a GUN!? LooooooooooL!
Seriously Voldy liked when his victims were dieing slowly and well with a gun.......hm there is no easier way to die..............just point gun at your head!
voldy didn't kill his victims slowly! he used avada kedavra and that kills people instantly!! it's basically like a gun only no blood and u have a 100% chance of killing the person u aimed at. _________________
DON'T EAT THE DAISIES
Voldy with a GUN!? LooooooooooL!
Seriously Voldy liked when his victims were dieing slowly and well with a gun.......hm there is no easier way to die..............just point gun at your head!
voldy didn't kill his victims slowly! he used avada kedavra and that kills people instantly!! it's basically like a gun only no blood and u have a 100% chance of killing the person u aimed at.
Actually, Jo originally had more gruesome deaths in mind for Harry's parents, and I'm willing to be that she would have kept the same theme for the other characters' deaths, but then her mother died while she was writing PS. She decided to make the deaths of Harry's parents quick and as painless as possible after watching her mother suffer. I think that she just decided to gie Voldemort a style when it came to killing and stuck with that AK for that reason. _________________
Please support the Diabetes Walk
Actually, Jo originally had more gruesome deaths in mind for Harry's parents, and I'm willing to be that she would have kept the same theme for the other characters' deaths, but then her mother died while she was writing PS. She decided to make the deaths of Harry's parents quick and as painless as possible after watching her mother suffer. I think that she just decided to gie Voldemort a style when it came to killing and stuck with that AK for that reason.
I suspect if a wicked wizard knows how to perform AK in a special way, he can use it to kill while making a horcrux. Rowling just didn't tell!
Why wouldn't harry grenade the horcruxes in part 7? Could have been effective.
Because in order to destroy a Horcrux you need either fiendfyre or basilisk venom.
or gryffindor's sword
use a gun to destroy that _________________
Quote:
dad's really disappointed in me because I accidently said "just because your a lesbian..." to my brother and there were lesbians behind us and there like..."huh?"
also, voldemort also is so proud because hes the best wizard ever (or so he believes). a gun would kind of contradict this....if hes the best wizard ever, why would he need a gun? _________________
Why wouldn't harry grenade the horcruxes in part 7? Could have been effective.
Because in order to destroy a Horcrux you need either fiendfyre or basilisk venom.
or gryffindor's sword
use a gun to destroy that
First of all, the sword didnt't destroy the Horcruxes, the basilisk venom inbedded in the sword did.
Second of all... how can a gun destroy a sword? Either it will leave a bullet hole, or bounce off, lol. Either way, the venom will still exist in the pieces of sword. _________________ ^made by Fiendfyre
Why wouldn't harry grenade the horcruxes in part 7? Could have been effective.
Because in order to destroy a Horcrux you need either fiendfyre or basilisk venom.
or gryffindor's sword
use a gun to destroy that
First of all, the sword didnt't destroy the Horcruxes, the basilisk venom inbedded in the sword did.
Second of all... how can a gun destroy a sword? Either it will leave a bullet hole, or bounce off, lol. Either way, the venom will still exist in the pieces of sword.
shoot the weilder of the sword, works better _________________ <-evan S cool
In book 4, there was mention that certain muggle inventions would not work on the grounds because of protective magic.
that is actually a great idea because nowadays with all these muggle kids going awol on campus... hogwarts has good ideas _________________ <-evan S cool
Maybe Voldemort wouldn't have used a gun, and because of the horcruxes would have been hard to kill with a gun - but it would be reasonable to think that the Order could mow down some Death Eaters with a gun, or vice versa. Magic wouldn't protect you if you were caught off guard and didn't have a chance to try and deflect the shot.
Rules
FAQ
Search
Memberlist
Usergroups
Register
Profile
Log in
<-evan S cool