Hey,I don't get it . How can you expect Dumbledore to came back to life after he has just died. I mean we even saw the body at the funeral, not to mention fawks leaves Hogwarts "forever".
I agree, I don't think he will come back. I think J.K is wanting Harry to prove he doesn't need the protection of Dumbledore to get rid of Voldermont.
Quote:
I just notised something, in GoF when Wormtail is getting LV's body back, he put his hand - the part where he goes hand of a servant willingly given- in the potion. Doesn't that mean he put some of himself in LV and if so does that mean that the debt that Wormtail owns Harry could be just a little bit transfered to LV?
Thats a nice connection, you may have found something!
Quote:
I am not sure about the idea of Snape saving Harry. At the moment it all seems quite far fetched to me.
I agree with ya there, but then Snape continues to confuse me in every book. One moment ya think its on one side, the next another. I really can't say what will happen with Snape...he's a very interesting character
Quote:
I don't think Harry would die either. Only one of them dies not the both of them, that would quite defeat the purpose of JKR writing the profecy.
I don't Harry is gunna die eithier.....She would probably lose a lot fans and it'd be kind of pointless for them to both die.
Quote:
PS could someone please tell me how to put pictures on my posts i have no idea how to do it
Sure! First you need an image hoster. Example: www.photobucket.com
Make an account there, sign in, and upload pictures from your PC. After you upload them you'll get 3 option below the picture. The URL, TAG, and IMG. You just copy the the IMG code into your post and your good to go! _________________
A lot of thanks to Phoenix, thanks for giving a helping hand . i can't believe i actually did something with a computer, couldn't have done without you... obviously.
THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU...to infinity
PS did i mention i was really chaffed with myself. haha in your face Mr H - my computer teacher - i can actually follow instructions. _________________ "WAR IS PEACE
FREEDOM IS SLAVERY
IGNORENCE IS STRENGHTH" - "1984" By George Orwell
Harry is the first one. I mean, JKR has killed everyone Harry loved, adults.
In HP: COS, when harry looks into the mirror, he sees his family. Not only his parens, but also apparently uncles and cusins. Where are they? Dead.
If Harry had a family, or at least, people he thinks they are, it would be much harder to let go in the end. Now, he is praclically alone. For me, it is much easier to know that he will die, now that he has barely something from his family (yes, I know he has his friends and Ron's family, but thay can't compare how we felt when we foud out that his Godfather was good, can we?).
I think that Hermione and Ron will live, but because Harry gives his life for them. Obiously, LV will die too, that is clear, I mean, the bad guys always die, nerville might die, and kill Bella, Spane, and of course, he will be good, he was just acting. I still hope that Sirius will appear, the body was never shown, and will die too, with Harry, or after him, and Hagrid will die too. Practically, all main characters will die. _________________ Sonita
Boy, Sonita you are grim! I don't even want to read the last book after your predictions!
To Horcrux and others:
We've discussed whether Dumbledore can possibly return on another thread called Dumbledore's return (page 2 of theories and speculation)
If you look at the website
www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com/introduction.html you will find answers and more questions to whether Dumbledore could be dead or not. He left many possible clues that could be interpreted in different ways. You state we saw his body at the funeral? No we didn't, we saw Hagrid carrying something wrapped which everyone assumed to be Dumbledore's Body.
1. Why did Dumbledore make Snape the Defense against the Dark Arts teacher if he knew the position was cursed and that Snape would be either dying or leaving Hogwarts? Could it be that he planned for Snape to have to leave?
2. The whole curse scene at the tower is wrong, all others killed by the death curse dropped instantly, but Dumbledore hung in the air a few seconds before tumbling over the embattlements. Why was there such an emphasis on silent spells etc during this book? Could Snape have silently said a different spell that had the effect of sending Dumbledore over the embattlements?
3. The description is of Dumbledore tumbling over the embattlements like a rag doll in which he fell at least 90+ feet to the ground. How come there isn't more damage to the body? Surely, there should have been some post mortem damage. He was found spread eagle with his glasses aschew and a drop of blood coming from his mouth. The body doesn't bleed after death and his glasses stayed on his face during a 90+ foot fall? What if after he left the wall he or Snape said the unfreezing spell,
maybe Dumbledore did the "aressto momentum" spell so he floated to the ground. He then could have drunk the sleeping draught, Known as the Draught of the Living Death.
Why would JKR leave so many clues to a possible outcome if she didn't plan to use it? Maybe Dumbledore comes back for the final battle with LV and ends up dying then. It's more plausible than you presently think.
4. I never thought of that wormtail connection and find it interesting, but we don't know if those kinds of debts are carried in the flesh, the blood, or the soul (essence) of the person.
5. Many people think the reason for Snape to turn away from the dark side was that he hurt and betrayed lily. I don't buy that reason. Snape owed James. James did something that Snape could never forgive him for, James saved Snape's life. We know that there is this cosmic karmic bond that forms when one wizard saves another. When Snape gave LV the info about the propecy he unwittingly betrayed the csomic karmic bond with James and has been trying to correct the problem ever since by helping DD and Harry. Both Snape and Pettigrew may end up betraying LV in some way during the last book. That could be giving one's life for another who knows?
6. The Order still exists, we don't know who the new leader will be though. _________________ You're just jealous cause the voices only talk to me!
Boy, Pensive, you pay too much attention to the book!
I would have never thought about those things... I mean, I just get half of the book when it is in english, even if it would have been in spanish, I would have never thought of all those details (specially in the Dumbledore thing)...
Gee... _________________ Sonita
Kind of thought provoking isn't it. JKR has all these threads of possibilites running through her books. You have to actually look for the clues. Did you check out the web site posted in my last post? Thank Pockets for that one. _________________ You're just jealous cause the voices only talk to me!
Pockets found some more to support the theory that DD may have faked his death. See the poll is snape truly evil. Pockets says the curse that Snape says isn't the same Kedvra curse. _________________ You're just jealous cause the voices only talk to me!
I to dont believe it is Harry because the book is written in harrys view so how would JKR beable to kill off harry when you are looking from harrys perspective
I to dont believe it is Harry because the book is written in harrys view so how would JKR beable to kill off harry when you are looking from harrys perspective
It can still be done. Think of it like a First Person Shooter. You play the game in a first person view, but you can still die. Harry would kind of be describing his death (not intentionally) but stuff like “I started to feel cold, and I could feel all the blood been drained out of me”, _________________
Rules
FAQ
Search
Memberlist
Usergroups
Register
Profile
Log in
