[quote="rmcdo9"]harry potter is a horcrux, not nagani, that would explain why he can feel what voldermort feels, why he can see what volermort sees, the have the same wands, there are just so many sings pointing to it[/quote]
how can harry be a horcrux. Voldemort tried to kill him and failed. he could not be a horcrux because Voldemort lost the soul that was in him and he did not kill anyone to be able to rip his soul into another peice. sorry if i spoiled what you are thinking but i got a good point !!
i'm also think harry should be the hocrux.. why not.. so harry need to sacrifice himself to save all people.. but i'm confius because the fifth book says one of them should die.. if harry is the seventh horcrux voldermort should die.. but harry would die too... oh my god... i hope the last horcrux is not harry but if it would be like him.. i would sad... _________________
nope. the fifth book said neither can live while the other survives. so definitely one will die. but nothing suggests that the other cannot die as well. _________________
I love my handsome Erik
I am so happy more people have said no than yes, i would be rather disapointed if Harry was a Hocrux. I am sure JK won't end the book like that. _________________ Ravenclaw Rules!
i'm also think harry should be the hocrux.. why not.. so harry need to sacrifice himself to save all people.. but i'm confius because the fifth book says one of them should die.. if harry is the seventh horcrux voldermort should die.. but harry would die too... oh my god... i hope the last horcrux is not harry but if it would be like him.. i would sad...
look youre boardering the point here. how can he be DESTINED to kill a part of himiself. voldie is pretty freakin smart...as much as we all hate him. do you think he didnt think out the fact that in the prophecy, harry or voldemort has to die, so to place a part of his soul in a person who is capable of having feelings and revolting and is not at ALL predesposed to think and feel exactly like voldemort was smart? no i think nottt _________________
I think harry was supposed to die..why would voldemort perform avada kedavera on his own horcrux?? that's retarded and really doesn't follow any natural form of reasoning. _________________ "Proud?" said Harry. "Are you crazy? All those times I could've died and didn't manage it? They'll be furious...."
harry potter is a horcrux, not nagani, that would explain why he can feel what voldermort feels, why he can see what volermort sees, the have the same wands, there are just so many sings pointing to it
how can harry be a horcrux. Voldemort tried to kill him and failed. he could not be a horcrux because Voldemort lost the soul that was in him and he did not kill anyone to be able to rip his soul into another peice. sorry if i spoiled what you are thinking but i got a good point !!
um...actually voldemort killed two ppl before harry(Ummm HIS PARENT'S??!!)...but i don't support the horcrux theory. _________________ "Proud?" said Harry. "Are you crazy? All those times I could've died and didn't manage it? They'll be furious...."
I don't think so. You brought up reasonable points, but like Siddhu and Arya said, they can be explained by the scar. Also, if Harry was the Horcrux, don't you think we might have seen more of Voldemort in him? Sudden angry outbursts against his friends, perhaps, that seemed out of character for Harry? If Harry was a Horcrux, that means he would has some of Voldemort's soul in him... it would be rather hard to be all hero-y when you've got an evil wizard's soul, don't you think? Haha
Agreed.
I completely agree with your agreement.
i agree with your agreements. _________________ www.theboywholivedd.piczo.com
name: mona
house: gryffindor
wand: 11" cedar, phoenix feather
harry potter is a horcrux, not nagani, that would explain why he can feel what voldermort feels, why he can see what volermort sees, the have the same wands, there are just so many sings pointing to it
Spoiler:
turns out you were half right...he was a horcrux but so was nagini
Rules
FAQ
Search
Memberlist
Usergroups
Register
Profile
Log in
!!
