Harry Potter Forums

Posts: 7080 · Posted: July 26, 2007 2:47 pm Post subject: Death Screw up

I think they screwed Sirus's death up becuase:, First off in the book it isnt the Killing curse that kills suries, it says so..., yet in the movie sirus is hit by it and yet is able to smile? no
_________________

"Foolish Brother, If you want to kill me..then hate...Spite and survive Pathetically, Run and Run, and cling desperately to Life"

Posts: 130 · Joined: Jul 25, 2007 Location: WI Posts: 130

Yeah I know thats what I noticed too. Because in the book he didnt get hit by a killing curse so people still wondered if he was alive, but if he would have got hit by a killing curse that meant he was gone forever.

Posts: 109 · Joined: Jul 16, 2007 Location: office Posts: 109

...i thought it was weird too...u would think JKR would've said something when she saw it in the screenplay *shrugs*

Posts: 1705 · Joined: Feb 24, 2007 Location: @ my computer Posts: 1705

ya i thought that i looked wired to
_________________
Harry potter RP name: Zabini

Posts: 306 · Joined: Jul 25, 2007 Location: colorado Posts: 306

It did look weird...
what was that arch he fell into?
_________________

ara's mad dancing skills!

Posts: 7080 · Posted: July 26, 2007 6:03 pm Post subject:

On top of it all, he got hit by the curse and was able to smile before dieing? HOW THE F?
_________________

"Foolish Brother, If you want to kill me..then hate...Spite and survive Pathetically, Run and Run, and cling desperately to Life"

Posts: 130 · Joined: Jul 25, 2007 Location: WI Posts: 130

Posts: 43 · Joined: Jul 12, 2007 Location: The Spectrum Posts: 43

I think it was stupid that they changed it like that. Have him get hit, fall through the arch, then take another 30 seconds after the battle is all said and done to explain why Sirius can't come back for all those in the audience who go "Huh?" and everybody will be hunky-dory, both from a book fan and movie fan's perspective.

Posts: 207 · Joined: Dec 21, 2007 Posts: 207

One Word:

Why? Sad

_________________

Posts: 136 · Joined: Dec 20, 2007 Posts: 136

well ti was a bit wierd how he smiled but he got hit by the curse and the kinda got sucked into the veil so it wasnt like in the book where it sed he fell in.
_________________

Posts: 8500 · Posted: January 7, 2008 3:31 pm Post subject:

I know Vincent doesn't post here anymore, but they have to change things to make them more dramatic. Also, I think everyone that dies goes into that "arch." Hence why Luna and Harry could hear those voices.
_________________

Posts: 51 · Joined: Jan 29, 2008 Location: maryland Posts: 51

what ...serious died?
_________________

<3 hermione granger
wand: 11 2/3", platinum oak, veela love

Posts: 17 · Joined: Feb 11, 2008 Posts: 17

In the book, they never actually stated which curse hit Sirus. And as for him smiling, he's supposed to have been laughing prior to that, so that when the curse hits, it appears as though he's still smiling.

Posts: 1927 · Joined: Feb 3, 2008 Posts: 1927

The scene was fine. I'm not concerned whether it copied the book exactly. It was close. I liked it.
_________________

Posts: 11494 · Joined: Aug 1, 2007 Location: Sharon, PA Posts: 11494

Posts: 1927 · Joined: Feb 3, 2008 Posts: 1927

No, it was fine. You forgot to take into account two things: the distance she was standing from Sirius, and the possible implications of Sirius standing so close to the Veil. Even JK Rowling didn't voice concern over it. The Avada Kedavra obviously wasn't compromised to give us a decent scene.
_________________

Posts: 11494 · Joined: Aug 1, 2007 Location: Sharon, PA Posts: 11494

Posts: 1927 · Joined: Feb 3, 2008 Posts: 1927

What are you unable to understand?
_________________

Posts: 116 · Joined: Jan 19, 2008 Posts: 116

I don't remember but in the movie do you actually hear the spell that bellatrix cast being said.

I know it was probably the killing curse, but what if it wasn't i'm sure there is at least one more spell that casts a green glow kind of thing.

Posts: 11494 · Joined: Aug 1, 2007 Location: Sharon, PA Posts: 11494

Posts: 28238 · Posted: February 16, 2008 6:04 am Post subject:

When I read the books, I thought it was the Killing Curse that hit Sirius, and then it knocked him back into the veil. It reminds me of DD's death, when the Killing Curse hit him, it threw him back and he toppled over the side of the tower. So if the Curse hadn't killed him, the fall would have. Same with Sirius, if the Curse hadn't killed him, the veil might have.
The fact is, we don't know if the movie messed up. JKR could have meant for Bellatrix to have hit Sirius with the Killing Curse, we don't know she didn't.
_________________

Blame it on a simple twist of fate ~ Bob Dylan
Team Cucumber, FTW!

Posts: 2184 · Posted: February 16, 2008 9:12 am Post subject:

Posts: 2184 · Posted: February 16, 2008 9:15 am Post subject:

Posts: 1927 · Joined: Feb 3, 2008 Posts: 1927

zengrenouille, when you're called up on a point you can't just ignore it and then repeat your previous statement.

There's really nothing wrong with Sirius' death in the movie. I mentioned the range of Bellatrix's curse as a possible reason of why he didn't die instantly, and then there's the Veil. We know it has a connection with death itself. So it could've had an influence over how his death was played out, like it did in the book.
_________________

Harry Potter Forums

Harry Potter Community and Bulletin Boards