Quite possibly...I read somewhere about some scene which i forget about in which some girl began to talk about how she knew sirius black wasnt a criminal because he was singing in a rock band as another name....how bizarre would it be if she was getting the two of them mixed up?
-no firenzy(sp?)
-the discovery of the room of requirement
-fred and georges escape
-sirius's death
-the department of mysteries wasnt really hard to get into
-luna lovegood's introduction
-DD's talk with Harry at the end was way too short
-they didnt visit mr. weasley at the hospital (forgot the name... st. mungos(sp))
[spoiler]
I agree with most of what you have said, alot was missed out. But I do have a couple of comments about what a couple of you said...
HRH2013 - I agree with most of what you said, you have pointed out loads of what I forgot but you have made a couple of mistakes.
1) Harry and Dudley WERE alone when the dementors attacked, the others were only there when the wether changed.
2) On the way to Umbridges office, Harry said they needed to use the floo network. Hermione said that they had been restricted, Harry then said not in Umbridges office - therefor explaining to anyone who had not read the book why he needed to use that fire.
3) This one isn't really a mistake but the kid with Ginger hair was Nigel and I am pritty sure he is in the book - Isn't he Colin Creevey's little brother??
Vlad - You siad Cho didn't cry during the kiss, she did. Harry said so when he was telling Ron and Hermione about it.
Severus Snape - You said the JK had said that they must not leave anything out that is important to the last book. You mentioned RAB, well that wasn't introduced untill the end of HBP, so why would it be in the film??
Yeah they left alot out, but the film was still awesome!!!!!
_________________ Bubbles
It's better to reign in Hell, than serve in Heaven
I bet you if I set up a poll for people that haven't read the books and just watched movie 5 would be so confused and about 90% of them would have no idea what was going on!
Anyways GOF was confussing to people who hadn't read the book. In any case the fact that Harry had gotten though to Sirius before wasn't that important. So you hate the film...get over it. _________________ Bubbles
It's better to reign in Hell, than serve in Heaven
Rules
FAQ
Search
Memberlist
Usergroups
Register
Profile
Log in
