Was Sirius actually hit with the AK curse or did he dodge it and step into the veil and get sucked in? Because if he got hit with it, it didn't kill him instantly like we have always seen in the movies and read in the books! This is the part I did not like, it bothers me. Why not just get stupified into the veil? He was dead before he went into the veil if the curse hit him, I don't get it...
I didn't get it either. Because if he was hit with the AK curse how in the world was he able to look at harry and such. It should've killed him instantly. It didn't make sense. Idk.
Sirius gets hit by the killing curse then falls backwards through the Veil.
is that from the book or the movie...cause in the book i dont remember it saying that and in the movie i guess he couldve been hit but he looked at harry and stuff so it seems like he just fell into the veil _________________ esrdfjykgdkuyrfk
I haven't seen the movie but I heard about this. In the book it is just a spell, you don't know what it is. But he is still alive, and he falls into the veil.
i expected so be soooo sad when it happened, but the emotion pretty much disapparated when i saw this scene. the movie was great, this was a big flaw though in my opinion. but it was my favorite movie so far
I don't think he looked at anyone. He definatly fell back into the veil, but to me it didn't seem like he actually looked at people, more that he was killed and fell back.
I will see it again and will pay more attention to it. But to me seeing it, that's what it looked like to me.
Like Cedric, he died with his eye's open, so did Sirius.
He may of been in the veil when it hit him so it wouldnt of actually hit him it would of hit the force field thing If that is possible it all went to quick so I will have to see it again. _________________
"I wasnt looking at its feet, I was a bit more preoccupied with its heads or maybe you didnt notice there were three!!!"
They should have made more effort with the last scene and not modified it so much. Sirius was kind of shocked when the spell hit him, just like in the book, although he kinda fidgeted before being thrown back. Avada Kedavra is instant death is it not?
And is it me, or do Stupefy, Expelliarmus and such all seem to knock back. Also there is no Reducto. And the colour is inconsistent. Isn't Expelliarmus meant to be red in colour?
Yeah it seemed like they were perfect with wordless spell casting and it kind of made me mad. but I expect things in the movie to be different and just accept them. But it bothers me still darn it!!!
And is it me, or do Stupefy, Expelliarmus and such all seem to knock back. Also there is no Reducto. And the colour is inconsistent. Isn't Expelliarmus meant to be red in colour?
Yes they do and yes there IS a Reducto jinx that destroys what it hits. _________________ CLICK!
in the book it is presumed to be a stunning spell because red light comes out of her wand that hits Sirius, sending him through the veil. _________________
I don't think he looked at anyone. He definatly fell back into the veil, but to me it didn't seem like he actually looked at people, more that he was killed and fell back.
I will see it again and will pay more attention to it. But to me seeing it, that's what it looked like to me.
Like Cedric, he died with his eye's open, so did Sirius.
From what I remember, his eyes moved after he got hit. _________________
Normally little things likee that bother me. But this film was so GREAT that to me it doesn't matter. Sirius death was craap in the book as well, so it no suprise to me that it looked crap in the film. JK should have found a better way to kill him.....if he really had to die.
I loved the film, it definatly the best one!!! I am just hoping HBP will be as good (it's my fav book). _________________ Bubbles
It's better to reign in Hell, than serve in Heaven
i was paying very close attention to this scene as i though it was going to be the best...........so this is what im 99% sure of...........
he did get hit with the AK curse......and he did look at harry........then fall into the veil.............
it must have been the producers fault...........idk............. _________________ "he can move as fast as Snape can when presented with a bottle of shampoo"
Rules
FAQ
Search
Memberlist
Usergroups
Register
Profile
Log in
